Now Reading: MISSED OPPORTUNITIES | The Chief Justice the Philippines Never Had
MISSED OPPORTUNITIES | The Chief Justice the Philippines Never Had
October 22, 2019 , 10:07 AM

By Dale Q De Vera, News5

October 21, 2019 – As a tradition, blue used to be the color that court employees wear during a retiring justice’s last attendance to a flag ceremony.

But, on Monday morning, they chose the country’s national color – red, white and blue – acceding to what the most senior member of the high bench, Senior Associate Justice Antonio T. Carpio, wants to see, an act that showed his genuine love for the country.

Carpio, known for defending the country’s sovereign rights in the South China Sea, also wanted the ceremony to be simple, unlike last week’s when Chief Justice Lucas Bersamin who was given military honors. No brass band played loud enough for everyone in Padre Faura street to know a very important person is the area.

He was the chief justice the country never had, a former top magistrate, Artemio Panganiban, described Carpio, paying tribute to the self-effacing legal giant who had enriched the court with his writings which became canonical.

“Regardless of the unceremonious way he was deprived of the official and legal title of chief justice, the Filipino nation represented by all of us gathered in this hall, hereby proclaim and acclaim as our esteemed and beloved CJ,” Panganiban told an earlier testimonial lunch for Carpio, saying he did not mind missing five opportunities to become the highest judge of the country.

Panganiban said Carpio never wanted title honors and testimonials. “it is more important to be correct, to be honor-bound than to be titled grandiosely than to be damned in history.”

All but one of the so-called “gods of Padre Faura” showed up on Monday’s flag raising to bid Carpio an appropriate good bye. Only Associate Justice Andres Reyes Jr. missed the event for undisclosed reasons as the well-respected and most-loved justice received plaques of appreciation for his services.

Carpio’s legal “opinions reflect the consistent scholar: clear, erudite, strategic, and always with a perspective towards a just result that should benefit the Filipino people,’ said Associate Justice Marvic Leonen, reading the citation in his award.

Carpio’s writings “usually served as the platform that elevated discussion for all his colleagues.” Leonen added.

Carpio, who hails from Davao City, is the longest serving justice, earning his law degree from the University of Philippines and undergraduate studies from Ateneo de Manila University. He began his public career as chief presidential legal counsel during the presidency of Fidel Ramos in 1992 and was appointed to the high bench in 2001 by then President Gloria Macapagal Arroyo. On five occasions, he served as acting chief justice but was bypassed by two presidents – Benigno Aquino and Rodrigo Duterte.

He has written 935 decisions, 79 dissenting opinions, 30 concurring opinions, 13 separate opinions, a testament to his integrity and independence as a member of the high tribunal.

As he walked toward the podium to address the court, he was welcomed by a thunderous applause, a sign of how well-loved. Acknowledging the crowd’s gesture, Carpio recounted the years he spent in the Judiciary, “18 years ago I stood here on this very spot to introduce myself as the newly appointed justice of the court. I then asked for your support to help me dispense justice to our people,” he said.

“After 18 years I stand here on this same spot to thank you for your unselfish support and to bid you farewell as I retire midnight of Friday this week,” when he turns 70 years old, the mandatory retirement age for court officials. Carpio is the 148th associate justice of the Supreme Court who had served as acting chief justice for total of eight months.

“You want your idea to prevail over the ideas of others, it’s a constant intellectual battle,” Carpio said, adding he will continue to serve the country in other capacity, giving talks and lectures on the West Philippine Sea as he continues doing research and write books.

“I am always available to defend our sovereign rights in the West Philippine Sea. I don’t have to have any formal position. they want my opinion my recommendation, I will give it willingly and gladly.” (MM)

More From News5
Tuloy ang war on drugs
Posibleng magbago ang istilo ng PNP sa war on drugs oras na lumabas ang resulta ng imbestigasyon ng Senado sa 'ninja cops' at agaw-bato issue.
Published On: October 16, 2019
Smuggled na yosi sa Zamboanga City
Narekober sa sasakyan sa Baliwasan Seaside ang kahun-kahong smuggled na sigarilyo.
Published On: October 16, 2019
Robredo sa naging galaw ng protesta ni Marcos
Mabuting balita raw na isasapubliko na ang committee report ng Presidential Electoral Tribunal, ayon kay VP Leni Robredo, para malaman ng publiko ang nangyari sa naging recount sa mga boto sa tatlong pilot provinces na pinili ng nagpoprotestang si dating senador Bongbong Marcos.
Published On: October 16, 2019
May plano ang gobyerno sa traffic -Panelo
Tanungin daw muna ng mga kritiko ang mga concerned department kung anong plano para maibsan ang matinding traffic sa Metro Manila bago mag-criticize, ayon kay Sec. Salvador Panelo. Kasunod ito ng mungkahit ni Bayan secretary-general Renato Reyes na dapat integrated ang transport system ng bansa, at ng pahayag niyang hindi sapat ang infrastructure projects sa ilalim ng Build, Build, Build para maresolba ang traffic issue.
Published On: October 16, 2019
Kabit ni mister, bestfriend ni misis
'Di lubos akalain ni Jeisa na pati bestfriend niya ay mapapabilang sa mahabang listahan ng mga naging babae ng kanyang mister. Ang masaklap, nagagawa pa raw siyang saktan ng asawa sa tuwing pagsasabihan sa kanyang pambababae.
Published On: October 16, 2019
SEA Games trivia: Athletics
Nakilala si Lydia de Vega bilang 'Asia's Sprint Queen' noong 1980s habang 'Long Jump Queen' naman si Elma Muros sa SEA Games atheletics.
Published On: October 16, 2019
SEA Games trivia: Volleyball
Anim na gintong medalya na ang inuwi ng Pilipinas sa women's volleyball.
Published On: October 16, 2019
SEA Games trivia: Gymnastics
Unang nakilala si Bea Lucero sa 1987 SEA Games matapos masungkit ang dalawang gintong medalya sa individual overall at balance beam events.
Published On: October 16, 2019
Testigo sa pagdinig sa GCTA, ibinunyag na may 'GCTA fo sale' sa Bilibid
Ibinunyag ni Yolanda Camelon, isa sa mga testigo sa pagdinig kaugnay ng GCTA, kung paano siya inalok ni Correctional Sr. Insp. Mabel Bansil na magbayad para makalaya ang kanyang asawang nakakulong sa Bilibid.
Published On: September 16, 2019
WOTD | Emancipation
Ang Emancipation ay kung saan ang pagiging 18-taong gulang ng isang Pilipino ang nagbibigay sa kanya ng lahat ng karapatan para kumilos nang may legal effect. Alamin ang iba't ibang termino sa usapang legal kasama si Atty. Mel Sta. Maria
Published On: September 16, 2019
Top Stories
UNANIMOUSLY | House panel OKs 5% tax on POGOs
(NOVEMBER 18, 2019) – The ways and means panel at the lower house of Congress has approved a bill imposing new taxes on the controversial Phi
Published On: November 18, 2019
55-YEAR-OLD MAN | China’s Inner Mongolia reports fresh bubonic plague case
(NOVEMBER 17, 2019) BEIJING, CHINA (Reuters) – China’s Inner Mongolia reported a fresh, confirmed case of bubonic plague on Sunday, des
Published On: November 18, 2019
FOCUS ON OTHER CLUSTERS | PNP questions Robredo’s request on high-value drug targets
NOVEMBER 18, 2019 – The Philippine National Police (PNP) on Monday raised concerns on the vice president’s request to be given a copy of a
Published On: November 18, 2019
VP ASSURES DUTERTE | Robredo ‘will not disclose’ sensitive info on drug war
NOVEMBER 18, 2019 – Vice President Leni Robredo on Monday assured the president she will keep the integrity of state secrets, including all
Published On: November 18, 2019
WORLD DAY OF THE POOR | Pope hosts lunch for 1,500 needy people
VATICAN CITY (Reuters) – Pope Francis hosted 1,500 homeless and needy people for lunch on Sunday as the Roman Catholic Church marked its Worl
Published On: November 18, 2019