Now Reading: MISSED OPPORTUNITIES | The Chief Justice the Philippines Never Had
MISSED OPPORTUNITIES | The Chief Justice the Philippines Never Had
October 22, 2019 , 10:07 AM

By Dale Q De Vera, News5

October 21, 2019 – As a tradition, blue used to be the color that court employees wear during a retiring justice’s last attendance to a flag ceremony.

But, on Monday morning, they chose the country’s national color – red, white and blue – acceding to what the most senior member of the high bench, Senior Associate Justice Antonio T. Carpio, wants to see, an act that showed his genuine love for the country.

Carpio, known for defending the country’s sovereign rights in the South China Sea, also wanted the ceremony to be simple, unlike last week’s when Chief Justice Lucas Bersamin who was given military honors. No brass band played loud enough for everyone in Padre Faura street to know a very important person is the area.

He was the chief justice the country never had, a former top magistrate, Artemio Panganiban, described Carpio, paying tribute to the self-effacing legal giant who had enriched the court with his writings which became canonical.

“Regardless of the unceremonious way he was deprived of the official and legal title of chief justice, the Filipino nation represented by all of us gathered in this hall, hereby proclaim and acclaim as our esteemed and beloved CJ,” Panganiban told an earlier testimonial lunch for Carpio, saying he did not mind missing five opportunities to become the highest judge of the country.

Panganiban said Carpio never wanted title honors and testimonials. “it is more important to be correct, to be honor-bound than to be titled grandiosely than to be damned in history.”

All but one of the so-called “gods of Padre Faura” showed up on Monday’s flag raising to bid Carpio an appropriate good bye. Only Associate Justice Andres Reyes Jr. missed the event for undisclosed reasons as the well-respected and most-loved justice received plaques of appreciation for his services.

Carpio’s legal “opinions reflect the consistent scholar: clear, erudite, strategic, and always with a perspective towards a just result that should benefit the Filipino people,’ said Associate Justice Marvic Leonen, reading the citation in his award.

Carpio’s writings “usually served as the platform that elevated discussion for all his colleagues.” Leonen added.

Carpio, who hails from Davao City, is the longest serving justice, earning his law degree from the University of Philippines and undergraduate studies from Ateneo de Manila University. He began his public career as chief presidential legal counsel during the presidency of Fidel Ramos in 1992 and was appointed to the high bench in 2001 by then President Gloria Macapagal Arroyo. On five occasions, he served as acting chief justice but was bypassed by two presidents – Benigno Aquino and Rodrigo Duterte.

He has written 935 decisions, 79 dissenting opinions, 30 concurring opinions, 13 separate opinions, a testament to his integrity and independence as a member of the high tribunal.

As he walked toward the podium to address the court, he was welcomed by a thunderous applause, a sign of how well-loved. Acknowledging the crowd’s gesture, Carpio recounted the years he spent in the Judiciary, “18 years ago I stood here on this very spot to introduce myself as the newly appointed justice of the court. I then asked for your support to help me dispense justice to our people,” he said.

“After 18 years I stand here on this same spot to thank you for your unselfish support and to bid you farewell as I retire midnight of Friday this week,” when he turns 70 years old, the mandatory retirement age for court officials. Carpio is the 148th associate justice of the Supreme Court who had served as acting chief justice for total of eight months.

“You want your idea to prevail over the ideas of others, it’s a constant intellectual battle,” Carpio said, adding he will continue to serve the country in other capacity, giving talks and lectures on the West Philippine Sea as he continues doing research and write books.

“I am always available to defend our sovereign rights in the West Philippine Sea. I don’t have to have any formal position. they want my opinion my recommendation, I will give it willingly and gladly.” (MM)

More From News5
Ex-FHM model sa drug buy-bust
Nasabat sa dating modelo ang ilang pakete ng shabu, ecstacy at pipe para sa liquid shabu na ibinibenta raw sa online store.
Published On: March 2, 2020
2020 Tokyo Olympics, tuloy sa kabila ng banta ng COVID-19
Tiniyak ng local organizers na handa silang protektahan kontra COVID-19 ang libu-libong atleta na lalahok sa Olympics. For more videos, visit us at www.news5.com.ph.
Published On: March 2, 2020
Sen. Drilon, naghain ng concurrent resolution sa ABS-CBN franchise extension
Mas mabilis ang proseso sa concurrent resolution dahil pag-apruba lamang ng Kamara at Senado ang kailangan para mapalawig hanggang June 30, 2020 ang prangkisa ng ABS-CBN. | via Greg Gregorio. For more videos, visit us at www.news5.com.ph.
Published On: March 2, 2020
Apology ng ABS-CBN, tinanggap na ni Duterte
Tinanggap na ni Pres. Duterte ang paumanhin ng ABS-CBN sa hindi nito pag-ere ng kanyang political advertisements noong 2016 elections. Natanong din siya tungkol sa quo warranto petition ng Office of the Solicitor General na pinapawalang bisa ang prangkisa ng broadcast network. | via Maricel Halili For more videos, visit us at www.news5.com.ph.
Published On: March 2, 2020
Jovie Espenido, 'cleared' na sa droga sa region 6
Nilinaw ng PNP na hindi pa final ang desisyon dahil sa isasailalim pa sa national level validation ang pagkakadawit ni P/Lt. Col. Jovie Espenido sa drug watchlist. For more videos, visit us at www.news5.com.ph.
Published On: March 2, 2020
Pag-iingat ng simbahan vs. COVID-19 ngayong Semana Santa
Maraming simbahan ngayong Ash Wednesday ang ibinudbod sa bunbunan imbes na ipinahid sa noo ang abo bilang pag-iingat laban sa coronavirus disease. | via Jen Calimon. For more videos, visit us at www.news5.com.ph.
Published On: March 2, 2020
Kinompronta ni Calida ang isang ABS CBN reporter
"Ikaw, lagi mo akong binabanatan ha." Kinompronta ni Solicitor General Jose Calida ang isang reporter ng ABS-CBN nang manghingi ito ng kopya ng petition for quo warranto para sa pagpapawalang-bisa ng prangkisa ng network.
Published On: February 17, 2020
Nilinaw ni Sec. Panelo ang naging confusion sa pagkansela sa VFA
Ipinaliwanag ni Sec. Salvador Panelo na nagkalituhan daw sa tenses na ginamit kaya magkaiba ang naging pahayag nila ni Defense Sec. Delfin Lorenzana tungkol sa pagpapasa ng termination notice ng Visiting Forces Agreement sa Amerika. Sinabi rin ni Panelo na mas mahalagang malaman na hindi magbabago ang isip ng Pangulo sa isyu.
Published On: February 17, 2020
Babaeng astronaut na bumalik sa mundo, gumawa ng record
328 na araw nananatili sa space ang American astronaut na si Christina Koch. For more videos, visit us at www.news5.com.ph.
Published On: February 17, 2020
Inflation forecast para sa 2020, itinaas ng BSP
Posibleng pumalo sa 3% ang inflation o kabuuang pagtaas ng presyo ng mga bilihin at serbisyo ngayong taon, batay sa pagtataya ng Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas. For more videos, visit us at www.news5.com.ph.
Published On: February 17, 2020
Top Stories
SNATCHERS | Monkeys steal coronavirus blood samples in India
LUCKNOW, India (Reuters) – A troop of monkeys in India attacked a medical official and snatched away blood samples of patients who had tested
Published On: May 29, 2020
‘LATE’ CASE PILE-UP | DOH records 1,046 new cases on Friday
(MAY 29, 2020) – Coronavirus disease (COVID-19) cases in the Philippines grew by 1,046 on Friday, hiking the running total to 16,634 based on
Published On: May 29, 2020
BODY COUNT | City of Moscow revises up its coronavirus death toll for April after criticism
MOSCOW (Reuters) – The city of Moscow has issued a revised version of its coronavirus death toll for April after criticism of its initial fig
Published On: May 29, 2020
COVID AID | Philippines secures combined P63 billion loans from China-backed AIIB and World Bank
(MAY 29, 2020) – The Philippines secured two separate loans amounting to a combined $1.25 billion, or over P63.2 billion, to aid in its fight
Published On: May 29, 2020
NOT ALL FRESH CASES | DOH explains record spike in COVID-19 cases yesterday
(MAY 29, 2020) – The Department of Health on Friday clarified the record spike of coronavirus disease (COVID-19) cases reported in the Philip
Published On: May 29, 2020